Written 6/19/26; Updated 6/19/2026

What
Exploring the lifetime cost of pet insurance for my dog
Why
To figure out if it’s worth the money
Dog Profile
Age: 2020 — Current (6 Years)
Species: Dog
Breed: Mixed (Coonhound mix)
Size: 70 lbs
Pre-Existing/Major Health Conditions: None
Predicted Health Issues: Nothing specific, she’s a mixed breed
Insurance Coverage: 2021 — Current
Cost
As of: 6/19/2026
| Year | Base Premium | Wellness Rider | Fees* |
| 2021 (1yo) | $406.85 | $248.40 | - |
| 2022 (2yo) | $406.85 | $248.40 | - |
| 2023 (3yo) | $450.83 | $277.50 | $2.00 |
| 2024 (4yo) | $527.80 | $277.50 | $3.25 |
| 2025 (5yo) | $946.05 | $277.50 | $3.25 |
| 2026 (6yo) | $1,161.14 | $277.50 | $3.25 |
*per monthly installment
| Premium | Rider | Fees | Grand Total |
| $3,899.52 | $1,606.8 | $141 | $5,647.32 |
Coverage Analysis
Major Medical Base Premium
| Base Premium Total | Reimbursement | Coverage (%) |
| $3,899.52 | $191.22 | 5% |
Wellness Rider
| Wellness Rider Total | Reimbursement | Coverage (%) |
| $1,606.8 | $1,180.00 | 73% |
Overall Total
| Total Cost | Reimbursement | Coverage |
| $5,647.32 | $1,396.22 | 25% |
Conclusion
Any insurance is a gamble. You have it just in case that major thing happens, because you never know.
Before this dog, I had 2 purebred dogs that ended up with major issues at the end of their lives. I thought I could just set aside money for them, but in the end, it wasn’t enough. Enter this dog in 2020 as a puppy. I decided right off the bat to get her insurance, despite her being a mixed breed which are known for being healthy animals. Didn’t think I’d ever use it. To date, I’ve used Major Medical for her twice (once at an E‑Vet for $23 out of $200 coverage, and the other for an ear infection for full coverage of $130). In total, they’ve paid out $191.22 for the $4,040.52 (including fees) that I’ve put into the “just in case” plan. This means, I’ve given them $3,849.30 in their pocket in 5 years. That’s $769.86 per year!!
I was unsure about the Wellness Rider when I first signed up yet decided to try it, anyways. Once you get rid of it, you’re never allowed to have it again for the life of your dog. Now, 5 years later, I do not recommend the Wellness Rider. Insurance is a gamble, but there’s no gamble about paying out for routine preventative care. So far, it’s covered 73% of my claims, meaning that I’ve given away (as of today in June 2026) $426.80, total, to the insurance company. That’s $85.36 a year. There’s nothing they cover in full, so, no, there’s no reason to have it. I could have put that money away and invested it, instead. Now, I have to say that I’ve only ever had to give my dog a dewormer medication (Insurance paid $25 of the $49.24) and some ear medication (insurance covered the $24.82 in full) nothing more. I also don’t use the pharmacy card discount (through Walmart) because she really doesn’t need regular medications. Yet.
What will I do now? Given that the premium jumped $100 to $420 to $250 a year from 2023–2026? I don’t know. It’s common that insurance jumps as years progress (just look at human insurance), but as she only gets older, how high will it go? I am ashamed to admit that I never noticed how high it got since I started; just assumed that it would go up or I was spending too much somewhere else. DANG, though!! Originally, I was going to play this all the way through her life and do the calculations, and decide whether it’s worth it or not, but… at this rate, I’m better off just saving the $855.22 a year they pocket from me and investing it! Especially if I only get back 5% of it and the rest is going to someone else. The question is: what will she need in the future? It’s hard to know… Just one surgery could wipe me out. And we all know how cost has only skyrocketed in recent times for everything…
Common Dog Procedures (Depending on where you live)
- Spay/Neuter: ~$300 — $500
- Dental: ~$800 — $3,000
- Lumps/Tumors: ~$800 — $2,000
- Bloat: $2,000 — $8,000
- Slipped Disc: $6,000 — $11,000
- Joint Surgeries (e.g. hip dysplasia): ~$3,000 — $10,000
- Cancer: $1000 — $10,000+
When you look at it like that, one major surgery may pay for your dog’s entire life’s worth of insurance premiums… If, the insurance company doesn’t drop you the instant you try to make a major claim, of course.…
In a way, I’m wondering if the insurance companies try to outprice you so that you drop before they have to pay out big time as the dogs get older. They make more money off of young dogs with minimal health problems, after all. I have to decide, now, if I want to just drop the wellness rider and continue with major medical, or if I just drop it all together. I don’t know!! My dog means a lot to me. I had it happen before where I said that if my dog needed that much money in procedures, I might just put them down. However, when I was faced with that very situation, I decided I would rather be in debt than give up on that dog. He made it another 3 happy years with me. 100% worth it.
