Nintendo Switch Indie Game Recommendation List

Written 4/27/2025, updated 4/27/25

I’ve invested in and played sooo many indie games for the Nintendo Switch since I first got the console (and continue to scour the Recently Released page in the eShop for anything else fun), that I’m afraid to see exactly how much money I’ve spent on games in total. While many of them have been well worth it, many of them have been total busts that I wish I never wasted my money on. Here, I will list my recommendations and non-recommendations alongside those that are just kind of meh, in the hopes that maybe it will help someone else. Some of them will have a mini review attached

Games I enjoy are:

  • Point-and-click
  • Farming sims
  • Puzzle/mystery adventures
  • Parody
  • Action

I don’t like:

  • First-person view (makes me very ill)
  • Frustrating gameplay
  • If gameplay is good, I can forgive bad graphics, but not if it’s especially nasty
  • Poor translations
  • PvP

I also like Visual Novels and Kairosoft games, but they will be in different posts. I won’t add first-party games because the vast majority of the time there’s a reason that they are first-party. They’re GOOD. Almost like a breath of fresh air after playing lots of indie games.

** denotes Favorite games in the Yes column and ABSOLUTE WASTE OF MONEY in the No column

Yes

  • Arcane Arts Academy
  • Artifex Mundi games
  • **Barbarous: Tavern of Emyr
  • Brok the InvestiGator
  • **Big Farm Storya little short, but great
  • Breakfast Bar Tycoon
  • Broken Sword 5 – The Serpent’s Curse
  • Cape’s Escape Game series
  • Cooking Festival
  • **Crowns and Pawns: Kingdoms of Deceit
  • Darkestville Castle
  • **Demetrios – The BIG Cynical Adventureabsolutely hilarious even if the graphics are unattractive. Not bad, just unattractive, though I think it adds to the silliness
  • Disease ~Hidden Object~
  • Escape Trick: 35 Fateful Enigmasthough it made me horribly ill, this game launched my love of puzzle games. Walkthrough
  • **Everdream ValleyMy Walkthrough
  • **Fae FarmGreat, solid game. A little short.
  • Fishing Paradiso
  • FiveBN games
  • **Garden StoryVERY cute, awesome game. Too short!
  • Goetia
  • **Irony Curtain: From Matryoshka with LovePositively hilarious, awesome point-and-click
  • **Kitaris FablesSimilar to Ragnarok Online
  • Leisure Suit Larry Wet Dreams Don’t DryNSFW though mostly innuendo and lewd art. On the lower end of the recommendations, but fun overall
  • **Lost Horizon 1 & 2- good point-and-click puzzle adventure
  • Lost Phone game series
  • Mahjong Stories: Vampire RomanceShort, enjoyable
  • Metropolis: Lux Obscuraa little bit of NSFW, intense, short game
  • Mom Hid My Game!
  • **My Time at PortiaPlay this before Sandrock
  • **My Time at Sandrock
  • One Night Stand
  • Pantsu Hunterweird yet fun game
  • Pocket QuestNot bad, a little dull
  • **Potion Permit
  • Prison Princesslots of fan service
  • **Puzzle Battler! MiraiSurprisingly awesome game
  • **Puzzle Quest: The Legend ReturnsFantastic just like the original
  • **Root Letter: Last AnswerNEATO game. Very much enjoyed it. You can play with either animated or live graphics. Insight into Japanese life
  • Secret Files games series
  • Sentimental Death Loopdisturbing yet interesting. My Walkthrough
  • Sherlock Holmes and the Hound of the Baskervilles
  • **The Testament of Sherlock HolmesMy Walkthrough
  • **Songbird SymphonyMy Walkthrough (incomplete)
  • **Spirit of the IslandGood. Short and repetitive, but fun
  • **Stranded Sails: Explorers of the Cursed Islandsthought I wouldn’t like it at first, but it grew on me, and I had a good time playing
  • **Summer in MaraGood game, a little slow to start. All other games in the series are not nearly as good
  • **Tell Me Your StoryReally nice game. My Walkthrough
  • The House of Davinci Series – Nice puzzle games. My Walkthrough
  • The Mahjong Huntress
  • **The Raven RemasteredVery much enjoyed this game and the music
  • Time on Frog Islandshort
  • **True Fear: Forsaken Souls Series – Finally releasing the 3rd game this year 2025! My Review
  • **Turnip Boy Commits Tax EvasionAMAZING game!
  • Turnip Boy Robs a BankGood, just not as good as the first game. My Walkthrough
  • **Voezgreat music/stepmania type of game
  • **Welcome to Primrose Lake
  • **Yonder: The Cloud Catcher ChroniclesREALLY liked this game despite some the shortcomings

Ehh

  • Car Mechanic Simulator
  • Castaway ParadiseReview
  • Chex Quest HDI played the holy heck out of the original and for some reason the remake doesn’t hit right. It’s somehow better yet clunky and while it’s cool to have remade such an old game, didn’t like it much
  • Commander Keen in Keen Dreamsdoesn’t hit like it did in the 90s
  • Electrician Simulator
  • Enchanting Mahjong Matchgreat if you like speed mahjong games and unlocking illustrations of females
  • Fabledom Ehh. The controls aren’t clear and seem to be made for PC. Could be a good game
  • Fall of the New Age: Collector’s EditionI really enjoy this type of game, but this was very unintuitive. I’ll still buy these types of games, though because I have an insatiable appetite for them. My Walkthrough
  • Gems of Warmade by creators of Puzzle Quest. I just dislike things you have to play online PvP
  • Half Past FateGood story, just put me to sleep at least 10 times while playing it. Boring… or relaxing…
  • Horse Tales: Emerald Valley RanchCould be good. Made me horribly ill
  • Hungry Shark Worldfun for about 30 minutes
  • Japanese Nekosama Escape: The Local Train
  • Jewel Fight: Heroes of Legend: Similar to Puzzle Quest, not nearly as good
  • Lego Worldsnausea!!
  • Long Ago: A Puzzle TaleMisleading cover art. Repetitive and boring puzzle game
  • Love on LeaveInteractive visual novel game. Played halfway and then stopped
  • Monster Prom: XXLEhhh
  • Nelke & The Legendary Alchemists “Ateliers of the New World”Put me to sleep a few times, but overall fun. Atelier series crossover
  • OceanhornSolid gameplay, just couldn’t get over how it’s a shameless Zelda knockoff
  • Paradise Lostkind of creepy, just an ehh game. Great graphics
  • Reminiscence in the Nightit’s okay…
  • Rune Lord
  • Sherlock Purr 2 Made me ill instantly
  • Storm Tale 2match-3 and hidden object. Just eh.
  • Sunseed IslandGame content behind paywall. Unable to zoom in and out of map, slow. Could be good
  • The Book of Unwritten Tales 2It’s actually a solid game. I just stopped playing halfway because I lost interest
  • The Future You’ve Been Dreaming ofIt’s good. Different. Fan-servicey. Just repetitive to unlock everything. My Walkthrough
  • Legacy Games games – They’re okaaaay. Gameplay not the best. At least voice acting is better than others and graphics are good
  • Yesterday OriginsIt seemed good at first, and then something bothered me about it, gave me a headache, and then I stopped playing it about halfway through
  • Yooka-LayleeWanted to enjoy it. Just kind of fell flat

No

  • Alba premise seemed cute, but game is insanely boring
  • Buried Alive: Breathless Rescuemade me ill immediately
  • **Cop Car Police Simulator ChaseTerrible, terrible game all around
  • Deponia series – As much as I love point and click parody games, I disliked this whole series. I found it to unintuitive and tremendously disliked the characters
  • Detective Di: The Silk Rose Murders
  • Doodle HuntI dunno, I thought I’d enjoy something so simple more, but I hated it.
  • EroblastI loved HuniePop and thought this would similar. I really hated the characters and the whole texting thing
  • **Frederic game series – I just really really hated these games. Wish I’d never wasted money on them
  • Gal*Gun 2Way too annoying
  • **Grow: Song of the Evertreevery disappointed by this game especially having loved a different game they made
  • Half Past Fate: Romantic Distancinggave it a try, very boring
  • **Harvest LifeQuit within 5 minutes of trying it. UGLY graphics, just awful game
  • Hokko LifeAnimal Crossing knockoff, boring. My Review
  • **Koa and the Five Pirates of Marautter disappointment after playing the other games in the series
  • Leisure Suit Larry Wet Dreams Dry TwiceToo much back and forth, loses the spirit of the first game, not funny. Unintuitive, overall repulsive. Does offer the explicit, raunchy stuff missing from the first game.
  • Let’s SchoolControls better suited to PC
  • Life in Willowdale: Farm AdventuresLooks like it should be good. Didn’t make it past 10 minutes. Character very unattractive
  • Little Friends: Dogs & CatsHaving played Nintendogs way back when, this doesn’t even come close. Cute, but boring
  • Nora: The Wannabe Alchemistdon’t bother
  • Ocean Media games – They’re ugly, puzzles are bad, and overall, not recommended despite being one my favorite genres. All I do is spam the hint buttons
  • OmegaLabyrinth LifeNope. Thought it would be good. Lots of boobs.
  • **Orange SeasonTried really hard to like this game, but it’s been out for so long and still unpolished. Fell asleep several times playing it. NOT recommended.
  • Regular Factory Escape Roomnausea
  • Scheming Through the Zombie Apocalypse Ep 2: CagedEh. Played 15 minutes.
  • Sprout Valleylooked cute, but extremely confusing with no direction. Tried to like it.
  • Sword & Fairy Inn 2Clunky, not fun
  • Syberia 1 & 2
  • **Tardyjust nope
  • VTM Coteries of New York
  • **What Comes AfterSUPER short game, all you do is talk to dead things. Tries too hard to be deep. Just boring
  • **WindboundUggghh! I get frustrated just looking at the name. My Review
  • Yeah! You want “Those Games,” Right? So Here You Go!Yes, I wanted the pin pulling game. Yes, I played a few levels. No, I do NOT recommend.

Game Review: Hokko Life (Switch)

written 7/16/23, updated 7/22/23

Developed by Wonderscope Games and published by Team 17, Hokko Life is an adventure simulation released fully on September 27, 2022 for Steam, Switch, PS4, and Xbox One. It centers around the player who comes off the train into a dusty, slow town inhabited by bipedal, articulate animals, and then works to make it more habitable.

Rating: 2.5 out of 5

ESRB Rating/PEGI: E (Everyone)/3

Price: Paid $9.99 out of MSRP $19.99

Recommended: Only if you are desperate for more games like Animal Crossing

One Word Description: Copycat

Time Rewind Buy Again? No

  • Pros: Cute, simple, easy, design flexibility, pleasant graphics, lulling music
  • Cons: Very long title loading, unrefined, unclear, unalluring, small, game progression

Review

To be fair, I have not finished the game. In fact, I have only been playing “for a little while” according to my Switch. Also, apparently, the game plays horribly on the Switch as compared to other platforms. Admittedly, if there was a story of any sort for the character, then I’ve already forgotten. I think it might have been that your character overslept on the train and the small animal town you arrive in is the last stop. You arrive at night and come across a cafe (that looks eerily similar to Brewster’s The Roost) where some walking, talking animals are conversing. The elephant (effectively Brewster) offers you a room. Then the next morning, they say more words and send you out to run around the very small village, except you were supposed to talk to the Tom Nook character, a giraffe name Moss. Predictably, they offer you a house, you have to talk to all the villagers, and then they give you some tools.

Similar to other social simulation games, you restore the village back to vigor by renovating, crafting, decorating, finishing small quests for villagers, landscaping, completing larger quests for the town, etc. Interestingly enough, you are able to redecorate neighbors’ homes as you please, by moving stuff around.

Although I haven’t spent much time in the game, I feel like I already have beaten it and don’t need to finish it, because all of it is extremely predictable… And why is that? Because unfortunately, I simply cannot get over the fact that this game is blatantly an Animal Crossing knockoff. A mediocre knockoff. If you’re going to knock off a game, it needs to either be on par, better, or offer something vastly unique compared to the original game. This (so far) does NONE of that. I think I was about one hour in before my brain shut down so hard that it was a challenge to keep my eyes open.

After the initial play, I tried again with gusto, determined to give it a chance. Some elements don’t make sense, like: the town’s mayor Rosa, a pink, suit-wearing pig, tells you that she (he?) doesn’t have a building in town and you can’t talk to her until the building is finished being made. So…she just became mayor? Or just was never there? Was the village created a few days prior? After waiting a day or two, you can visit her, and effectively the mayor just allows you to either alter houses or build new ones for new inhabitants, except you talk to the elephant in the cafe for new residents? Playing on, the slow pace of the game eventually takes you to the resident entomologist who likes bugs and gives you a net. Cool. I love collecting things. Every time you catch a new butterfly, it takes an eternity to automatically load the encyclopedia listing for it, only to see a terrible graphic of a generic butterfly with different colors. I soon quit again after realizing that the game wants you to plant your own forest in order to collect enough wood to make planks to progress further in the game. I’d already been skipping days by sleeping so often, that it took any sort of fun away from the game. It has bad flow.

Delving into the past of the game, Robert Tatnell (according to Wikipedia), the game’s developer, originally intended the game to be much more like old-school Sim City type of games before morphing it into something akin to Animal Crossing. Development started in 2017, an early access released June of 2021 for Steam, and then the full version released September 2022.

Bottom Line: So, no, even only 2 hours into the game (I tried to pick it up again today a month after I bought it), I cannot recommend it unless you’re simply dying for another game just like Animal Crossing or have never played Animal Crossing before, or perhaps you have extra time and money to spare. If I could go back, I would not have bought it.

Game Goods

Cute, Relaxing: There’s no denying the mind numbing soothing quality of the game. It’s simple, there are animals, the graphics are pleasing, there is no killing, maiming, guns, or destruction (unless you count felling trees or plucking flowers). Similarly, the music is lulling and not grating. After a long, nasty day at work, this is a great way to just let the mind flow away, content with grooming a small town however you like.

Detailed: The interiors are detailed. You can tell the hardwood from the wood panel walls. There are butterflies, flowers to be picked, earthworms to gather. Time and effort certainly went into the game.

Familiar Gameplay: Crafting, building, planning, planting, chopping, digging, fishing, buying, collecting, talking, side quests… This game has everything a social simulation game fan wants.

Improvements: So far there are some improvements to Animal Crossing itself, such as smaller grids during house decorating allowing for finer furniture placement

Game Gripes

Loading: I don’t know about other game platforms, but the Switch’s game loading screen is painful. I actually timed it. The main loading screen takes an abysmal 1 minute and 13 seconds to finish, and then another 8 seconds to finally make it to the menu screen. I probably could floss my whole mouth in that same time. Then, the automatic loading screen for newly captured bugs is also interruptingly long.

The dreaded startup loading bar

Character Design: The graphics as a whole are pleasant. The animal inhabitants are cute (there’s an inexplicable disdain that I have for them, though… Maybe it’s the copycat thing). The character you play, however, is, well, ugly, imo. Something about the eyes, maybe? The color? There isn’t much customization available at all. And I have to look at them the whole time. Ugh.

Small Things: You can’t run, there’s only 1 speed. There’s no quick way to put away the tools. The game isn’t clear about whether or when it autosaves, and there’s no set Save button. It’s hard to tell which house is whose… Especially mine which is the only one with a mailbox. The cursor speed for redecorating or placing features/furniture is too fast, making it harder than necessary to accurately position items. Lack of refinement in areas. For example: I was chasing a butterfly and couldn’t catch it because it flew through a building.

Unalluring: As I mentioned in the review section above, I found it extremely dull. I would not have bought the game if I thought I’d be wasting my time. It had already looked like an Animal Crossing knockoff, and I still bought it with high hopes. Despite the decent graphics, something about the game is simply unappealing. My brain shuts off completely. Like, go-to-sleep shutoff. It extends beyond boring to an irrational loathing for a reason I can’t seem to comprehend. I don’t care what the characters are saying (and I totally understand how long it took someone to come up with and write the dialogue!) and I don’t care about them or the main character, at all.

Game Progression: The flow of the game is not smooth. Some parts work fine, but others are simply too slow and mundane. Others feel forced. Mostly, it was slow. Each piece of equipment takes too long to be unlocked. I see fish that beg to be caught, but I don’t even have a shovel yet, kind of deal. It takes days before the next piece of equipment or new crafting recipe becomes available.

Conclusion

Not gonna beat a dead horse here: I don’t like this game, and I don’t recommend it. I will, however, because I paid for it, and also for the sake of the person(s) who likely poured their heart and soul into it, TRY to progress further. I will update if my thoughts change.